The Han Dynasty suffered from
economic and social difficulties brought about by their greatest emperor, Han
Wudi. Han Wudi was responsible for some
beneficial things such as the Confucian educational system which would help men
prepare for government jobs. Other actions
of his weakened the Han Dynasty.
Expanding the empire into Korea and North Vietnam placed a lot of
economic strain and consumed a lot of the empire’s excess wealth. As a result, Han Wudi collected land from the
wealthy, often illegally, and raised taxes to restore some wealth. These two actions hurt their economy by
discouraging investments in manufacturing and trading.
Despite the fact that Han Wudi
brought down the economic and political structure of China, the best place to
intervene would be during the Later Han Dynasty. Han Wudi helped with the survival of China;
his conquests into central China conquered areas of the Xiongnu people. These conquests sent the Xiongnu into
disarray, thus ending the threat of Xiongnu army. Taking over before Wang Mang comes to power
does not seem to be the best place.
Tensions were already high from the degrading economy and development of
social distinctions. Taking over at this
time would be problematic because of the insurrection against Wang Mang by irritated
landlords and peasants. The best place
to take over would be the early Former Han dynasty. The Han dynasty was in a weakened state, but
they had the military to enforce boundaries against the Xiongnu. I would take power during this time and
distribute the land from landlords to peasants.
By learning from Wang Mang’s errors, I would take some of the military
power to enforce distribution of land.
This distribution of land would hopefully destroy social
distinctions. This would be done by
taxing the landlords to the point where they have to sell their land in order
to pay them, and the peasants would be taxed so that they would have enough
money to pay for food and a bit extra to save up to buy land from the
landlords. I would also unite factions
by establishing a common enemy. The enemy
would probably be the Xiongnu because China had already been keeping the
Xiongnu submissive and had been controlling the silk roads that supported the
Xiongnu.
I do agree to with you that Han Wudi's clash's with the Xiongnu lead to a weakened state and should have been avoided, I disagree with your concept of overtaxing the rich. This is due to the fact that Wang Mang's dynasty fell after he tried to reapportion land causing the Former Han to fall. Taxing the landowners would've lead to discontent and confusion causing the same result as occurred in 23 ce with the fall of the Former Han.
ReplyDeleteI agree with using power and force to redistribute the land. That's what I think is different from what Wang Mang did, so I disagree with Colin. I like the idea of establishing a common enemy but I don't think that the empire could probably handle it with all the reforms taking place.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you that the distribution of land will destroy the social distinction and will help the peasants pay for food, but I don't think taxing the landlords will help you take over their land. Overtaxing the landlords will lead to a rebellion.
ReplyDelete